.st0{fill:#FFFFFF;}

Are Coaches Using AI Wrong? 

5 Ways to Leverage Technology Without Losing Your Authority

Here's the uncomfortable truth: most coaches are approaching AI coaching like a shiny new hammer, and suddenly everything looks like a nail.

I'm watching brilliant coaches hand over their most valuable asset: their unique thinking: to algorithms that can't even push back when a client needs it most. It's like watching Banksy give his spray cans to a photocopier.

The real question isn't whether you should use AI. It's whether your AI coaching approach integrates with framework thinking and your authority frameworks to amplify your authority, or whether it accidentally erodes it.

TL;DR:
AI coaching tools are powerful, but real authority comes from weaving AI into your unique framework thinking. Don’t let technology replace your voice; instead, make it amplify your signature process and expertise. Use AI to scale your impact, but let your authority frameworks lead the way.

The AI Coaching Trap Most Experts Fall Into

Let me be blunt: AI is not a coaching replacement. It's information aggregation with a conversational interface. Effective AI coaching nests the tech inside your framework thinking, not in place of it.

When you challenge AI, it typically responds with some variation of "you're absolutely right" rather than providing the constructive resistance that creates real breakthroughs. Your clients don't need a digital yes-person; they need someone who can see their blind spots and guide them through uncomfortable growth.

The coaches who are winning with AI coaching aren't using it to replace their thinking. They're using it to amplify what makes them irreplaceable inside clear authority frameworks.

5 AI Coaching Moves to Leverage Technology Without Losing Your Authority

1. Use AI for Operations, Not Insight

The first rule of AI coaching? Keep it away from your core methodology.

AI excels at administrative excellence: scheduling, client matching, preliminary questionnaires, and follow-up sequences. These tasks eat your time without adding your unique value. Let technology handle the logistics so you can focus on what only you can provide. This is AI coaching done right, where tech supports your framework thinking and keeps your authority frameworks clear and consistent.

Think of it this way: would you rather spend 30 minutes crafting the perfect email sequence, or 30 minutes developing that breakthrough insight that transforms how your client sees their business? The choice becomes obvious when you frame it correctly.

Your authority comes from your thinking, not your typing. Use AI to eliminate the typing so more thinking can happen.

2. Create Transparency That Builds Trust

Where most coaches get it wrong is they treat AI coaching like a secret weapon rather than a declared tool.

Your clients deserve to know when AI is involved in their journey. But here's the twist: transparency actually strengthens your position when you frame it correctly.

"I use AI to handle the administrative side so I can spend 100% of our time together focused on your breakthrough" sounds very different from sneaking AI into your process and hoping nobody notices.

The coaches building lasting authority are the ones saying: "I've systematised everything that can be systematised, so what you get from me is pure, focused expertise." That's a positioning statement, not an admission of weakness.

reference worthy assets e1758464036827

3. Maintain Human Oversight as Your Competitive Advantage

AI might spot patterns, but it can't spot the pause in your client's voice that signals they're not telling you something important. It can't read the micro-expression that suggests they're afraid of their own success.

This is where your Framework Thinking becomes crucial. In AI coaching, AI processes data points while your framework thinking processes the human complexity that sits between those points.

Your way of thinking has the ability to become your Authority Framework® - your unique way of seeing problems and solutions will remain entirely yours when it's brought together inside a trademarked framework. AI can help you document them, present them, even scale them. But it cannot create them. That's your intellectual property, your authority DNA.

The moment you hand over your authority frameworks to AI is the moment you become replaceable. Keep your thinking human, use AI for everything else.

4. Address Privacy and Ethics Before Profit

The elephant in the room that many ignore is the data privacy in AI coaching conversations.

Your clients share their deepest business fears, personal limitations, and ambitious dreams. This isn't customer service chat data: this is the raw material of human transformation. Treating it carelessly doesn't just breach trust; it destroys the foundation of your authority.

The solution? Implement encryption that would make MI5 proud. Create data policies that prioritise your client's confidentiality above your operational convenience. Make privacy protection a cornerstone of your methodology, not an afterthought.

The coaches who build lasting authority are the ones their clients trust with everything. AI should support this trust, never compromise it.

Your stance on data governance matters and will give you the edge.

5. Position AI as Enhancement, Never Replacement

direct the narrative

Here's the reframe that changes everything: AI coaching isn't competing with your coaching: it's competing with your competitors who haven't figured this out yet.

Use AI within your authority framework processes to refine your research, polish your presentations, and streamline your content creation. But keep your client conversations, your breakthrough questions, and your framework development entirely human.

Think about the SPARK Process™ I developed. The Self phase - uncovering your Authority DNA - requires human intuition to spot patterns that feel obvious to you but are revolutionary to others. AI can't replicate that unconscious competence extraction.

The Premise phase demands the kind of provocative thinking that challenges conventional wisdom. AI, by design, aggregates conventional responses. It can't be contrarian in the way that creates genuine thought leadership.

When you reach the Art phase: transforming your ideas into visual frameworks: AI can become useful again as part of AI coaching. It can help refine your designs, suggest layout improvements, even generate multiple iterations. Yet a skilled designer will be your best friend over AI at this stage as you'll want to weave in your brand naturally rather than randomly generated icons. But the original framework flows from framework thinking, your unique way of seeing problems.

For the next stage - Reach - AI can totally integrate as you systemise and expand, creating content around your initial framework, finding new clients to connect with and streamline you communications. 

The last phase, Kudos, is outside the realm of AI, as this is where human connection, reputation and energy merge together as one and dance in harmony together as your framework begins to leave the legacy and expands beyond you. 

The Authority Test for AI Integration

Before implementing any AI coaching tool, ask yourself: Does this make me more uniquely valuable, or does it make me more replaceable?

If AI is doing work that only you should be doing: like creating your methodology, architecting your authority frameworks, facilitating breakthrough conversations, or developing your intellectual property: you're on the wrong path.

If AI is handling the work that anyone could do: like scheduling, transcription, or content formatting: you're amplifying your authority by focusing on what matters most.

The coaches thriving in the AI era aren't the ones avoiding technology. They're the ones using it so strategically that their human value becomes even more apparent by comparison.

Your Framework Advantage in an AI World

Coaches with proprietary frameworks will always outperform AI-dependent generalists because frameworks are thinking made visible.

While AI aggregates existing information, your frameworks create new ways of seeing. They don't just solve problems; they redefine how people understand their problems in the first place. This is the essence of framework thinking, and it's where AI coaching can support scale without diluting your originality.

When someone uses your framework, they're not just applying a tool: they're thinking like you think. That's intellectual influence, not information delivery. And it's something AI cannot replicate.

The Strategic Path Forward

The coaches building unshakeable authority aren't choosing between AI and human expertise. They're using AI coaching to amplify what makes them irreplaceable while eliminating everything that doesn't, positioning it inside clear authority frameworks.

Your thinking is your ability to see what others miss: these remain purely human advantages. Use AI to handle everything else within your authority frameworks, and watch your authority multiply.

The question isn't whether you should embrace AI. It's whether you're confident enough in your unique value to let technology handle the mundane so you can focus on the magnificent.

What aspect of your coaching could benefit from strategic AI coaching, sitting inside your framework thinking and authority frameworks, while strengthening rather than weakening your authority position?

Written by Susanna Reay, 09/21/2025

Susanna Reay is a multi award-winning coach, writer, and speaker who’s been bringing clarity, focus and structure into small businesses and entrepreneurial start-ups for over 20 years. Susanna brings a unique perspective informed by her training in design and business strategy, her life-long interest in psychology and strengths as an introverted online business builder. Her books, courses and mentoring have been the catalyst for growth for clients who’ve integrated Authority Frameworks® into their business. She helps the unseen be seen, heard and respected. Susanna serves her global audience from her English home.


You may also like

{"email":"Email address invalid","url":"Website address invalid","required":"Required field missing"}

Subscribe to the SPARKS newsletter now!

Please confirm